Talk About Network

Google





Professions > Philosophy Debate > Re: A Critique ...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 1 of 11 Topic 5129 of 5186
Post > Topic >>

Re: A Critique of Prof. Hubert Dreyfus' "Why Heideggerian AI failed"- a call for comments

by "Isaac" <groups@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Nov 15, 2008 at 07:46 PM

All,

I have critiqued in great detail a recent white paper by Prof. Hubert
Dreyfus entitled "Why Heideggerian AI Failed and how Fixing it would
Require
making it more Heideggerian" .  I can email a copy of it to whom ever is
interested. For his bio, see:
http://socrates.berkeley.edu/~hdreyfus/

I want to stimulate discussion on this topic by posting my critiques
little
by little and getting comments from the AI community on the news groups.
However, before I start I want to get a feel for how many know of his work
and/or would be interested in an intellectual debate for and against his
many anti-AI positions.

I hope many will respond to this posting with interest so I can begin
posting each part of this paper I find issues with and my reasoned
critique
for others to comment on.

Thanks,
Ariel-
 




 11 Posts in Topic:
Re: A Critique of Prof. Hubert Dreyfus' "Why Heideggerian AI fa
"Isaac" <gro  2008-11-15 19:46:37 
Re: A Critique of Prof. Hubert Dreyfus' "Why Heideggerian AI fai
Immortalist <reanimate  2008-11-15 19:55:07 
Re: A Critique of Prof. Hubert Dreyfus' "Why Heideggerian AI fai
"Isaac" <gro  2008-11-15 20:20:22 
Re: A Critique of Prof. Hubert Dreyfus' "Why Heideggerian AI fai
Publius <m.publius@[EM  2008-11-16 07:42:22 
Re: A Critique of Prof. Hubert Dreyfus' "Why Heideggerian AI fai
"Isaac" <gro  2008-11-16 03:52:57 
Re: A Critique of Prof. Hubert Dreyfus' "Why Heideggerian AI fai
Publius <m.publius@[EM  2008-11-16 17:31:20 
Re: A Critique of Prof. Hubert Dreyfus' "Why Heideggerian AI fai
"Isaac" <gro  2008-11-16 10:11:08 
Re: A Critique of Prof. Hubert Dreyfus' "Why Heideggerian AI fai
Immortalist <reanimate  2008-11-15 20:54:20 
Re: A Critique of Prof. Hubert Dreyfus' "Why Heideggerian AI fai
"Isaac" <gro  2008-11-15 21:57:16 
Re: A Critique of Prof. Hubert Dreyfus' "Why Heideggerian AI fai
Immortalist <reanimate  2008-11-15 22:48:55 
Re: A Critique of Prof. Hubert Dreyfus' "Why Heideggerian AI fai
"Isaac" <gro  2008-11-16 10:19:17 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
localhost-V2008-12-19 Wed Jan 7 20:12:36 PST 2009.