Talk About Network

Google


Register and Login
Nick
Password
Register create new account Sign up is FREE and you can post replies, new topics, bookmark posts and more!
Recover lost password


Professions > Biology > questioning the...
Latest [ Topics | Posts ] Archive Post A New Topic Post a Reply
<< Topic < Post Post 1 of 7 Topic 1084 of 1103
Post > Topic >>

questioning the idea that antibiotic soap promotes superbugs

by "adam russell" <adamrussell@[EMAIL PROTECTED] > Jun 9, 2008 at 09:21 AM

I keep hearing the idea sup****ted in the press that we shouldnt use 
antibiotic soaps because it will start to make germs immune.  Thinking
about 
how the "survival of the fittest" theory works, I dont see it applying 
though.  AFAIK there are two possible reasons for a species to grow
stronger 
due to culling the weak.  In breeders species killing the weak allows the 
stronger ones to breed strong+strong thus making more strong children. 
But 
germs obviously dont breed.  For germs the only mechanism I could see is
if 
you suppose that killing the weak ones leaves more food for the strong
ones 
thus allowing them to multiply faster.  But I seriously doubt that germs 
have any food shortage.  So I think that antibacterial soap while causing 
there to be a higher percentage of strong germs, would not make more of 
them.  They would multiply at exactly the same rate as before.  There
would 
not be more of them.

Sorry if this wasnt clear.  I hope that the idea was got across, and I
hope 
you dont think this is some kind of troll.  Just been thinking about it
and 
would like to get others thoughts on it.
 




 7 Posts in Topic:
questioning the idea that antibiotic soap promotes superbugs
"adam russell"   2008-06-09 09:21:48 
AW: questioning the idea that antibiotic soap promotes superbugs
"eduart wolf" &  2008-06-17 00:18:05 
Re: questioning the idea that antibiotic soap promotes superbugs
"adam russell"   2008-06-17 06:48:15 
AW: questioning the idea that antibiotic soap promotes superbugs
"eduart wolf" &  2008-06-17 22:12:59 
Re: questioning the idea that antibiotic soap promotes superbugs
"adam russell"   2008-06-18 09:31:10 
AW: questioning the idea that antibiotic soap promotes superbugs
"eduart wolf" &  2008-06-18 20:59:20 
Re: questioning the idea that antibiotic soap promotes superbugs
"adam russell"   2008-06-18 15:22:05 

Post A Reply:
  Go here to Signup

AddThis Feed Button


About - Advertising - Contact - Frequently Asked Questions - Privacy Policy - Terms of Use - Signup

Contact
tan12V112 Tue Dec 2 3:50:24 CST 2008.